MED–WINETRADERoman wine economy · Developing TRPDM
Research protocol · In development

Transferability is a question.
Not an assumption.

The proposed TRPDM framework will test how far a regional model of Roman wine production and distribution can travel — and what must change when it does.

This page presents the intended method, not completed analyses or validated results.

01 / Scope

Begin with a
controlled comparison.

Baseline: Campanian wine production and export, grounded in the doctoral study.

Primary comparison: Tarraconensis / Layetania, focusing on Pascual 1 and Dressel 2–4 evidence where comparable chronology and documentation permit.

Potential extensions: Alexandria and western Anatolia, assessed separately for the questions their evidence can answer. Production, reception and consumption contexts will not be treated as equivalent observations.

Exact chronological windows and spatial units will be fixed following the evidence audit. A shared commodity label alone does not establish comparability.

02 / Hypotheses

Four propositions to test.

H1 / Transferability

A shared core

Can a common set of variables account for patterns in both regional cases?

H2 / Calibration

Different parameters

Do coefficients or thresholds need to change when the framework moves to another region?

H3 / Modularity

Regional additions

Does adding a justified regional module improve explanation beyond the common core?

H4 / Discrepancy

Evidence before explanation

Can differences arise from research intensity, chronology or spatial uncertainty before an economic explanation is required?

03 / Workflow & work packages

From source to evaluation.

WP 01

Baseline audit & variable dictionary

Reconstruct the Campania model, distinguish observations from assumptions, and define variables, units, dependencies and expected outputs.

Deliverable: documented baseline and variable dictionary.
WP 02

Evidence selection & harmonisation

Evaluate chronology, provenance, context, spatial resolution, coverage and access conditions. Preserve original records alongside normalised values. Document counting conventions and avoid treating sherd totals as vessel totals.

Deliverable: source register, comparison matrix and standardised data structure.
WP 03

Spatial & economic modelling

Use GIS to examine terrain, production areas, accessibility and port connections. Define network nodes and links according to the evidence. Introduce economic variables only when their meanings and units can be justified.

Deliverable: reproducible analytical workflow and first comparative model.
WP 04

Transfer, calibration & uncertainty

Compare the shared core, a recalibrated version and a version with regional modules. Assess sensitivity to assumptions and data coverage. Where sufficient independent evidence exists, reserve it for evaluation rather than calibration.

Deliverable: transfer/calibration matrix, diagnostics and an account of limits.
WP 05

Interpretation, documentation & release

Interpret differences alongside archaeological visibility and historical context. Document reproducible steps, permissions and version history. Release the completed model through this website after validation.

Deliverable: methodological protocol, publication and model documentation; data and code as permitted.

These work packages describe the scientific sequence. Staffing, access agreements and delivery dates remain to be finalised.

04 / Evidence discipline

Absence of evidence
is not a zero.

Missing records will be distinguished from observed absence. Assemblage size, excavation intensity, publication history and preservation may affect the visibility of trade.

Amphora counts are proxies requiring interpretation; they are not direct measurements of traded wine volume. Content attribution, reuse, residuality and uncertain provenance must be considered.

Each input should retain its source, chronology, spatial precision, transformation history and confidence assessment. Observed evidence, inferred connections and simulated outputs will remain distinguishable.

05 / Analytical modules

A focused core.
Extensions where evidence permits.

GIS, routes, ports and networks

Terrain and accessibility analysis, production-to-port relationships, and terrestrial and maritime connectivity. Route costs and network metrics will be chosen for the scale and structure of the available evidence; inferred routes will be labelled as such.

Written sources, prices, taxation and intervention

Ancient texts and inscriptions will be assessed for date, locality, genre and representativeness. Prices, income and taxes will be optional evidence-based inputs, not assumed complete series. Institutional interventions can be explored as explicitly stated scenarios.

Comparative advantage and economic interpretation

Comparative advantage provides a possible interpretive hypothesis about relative production and exchange conditions. It will not be treated as proof that Roman markets met the assumptions of a modern economic model.

Experimental archaeology and container performance

Where suitable experiments and collaborators are available, capacity, handling, loading and loss estimates could help constrain transport scenarios. Experimental estimates will be distinguished from ancient observations.

Computation, simulation and software

Implementation should make assumptions inspectable and analyses reproducible. Simulation complexity will follow the research question and available evidence. An interactive demonstrator is a planned output, not an existing validated tool.

Research foundation

Built from an existing study.
Designed for a new test.

Karaçetin, A. O. (2023). Pax Romana Dönemi’nde Campania Şarabının Akdeniz’deki İhracat Modelinin Geliştirilmesi. Doctoral thesis, Ege University, Social Sciences Institute. Supervisor: Prof. Dr. Ahmet Kaan Şenol.

The thesis combines archaeological, historical, geographical and economic perspectives. Its export model provides the baseline to audit and develop, rather than a result assumed to hold across the Mediterranean.

2026 research proposal: From a Regional Export Model to a Transferable Framework: Digital-Economic Modelling of Roman Production and Distribution Systems. Prepared for TÜBİTAK 2219. The transfer, recalibration and regional-modularity framework informs the present research design.

This website offers an adapted public overview. The proposal is not evidence of awarded funding, confirmed access or completed partnerships. The methodological protocol will evolve as sources and collaborations are assessed.

Help shape the comparison

Does your evidence
challenge the model?

We welcome methodological criticism and conversations about comparable assemblages, recording practices and alternative explanations.

Contact the project ↗